Go to previous page Go up Go to next page

A Far Zone Contribution

A formal retardation expansion gives a divergent integral when we evaluate the gravitational field. Schematically the field h(τ,xi) at the field point (τ,xi) is given by (we omit the indices of the field for simplicity)

∫ ∑∞ n ∫ n h(τ,xi) ∼ d3y f-(τ-−-ε|⃗x-−-⃗y|,⃗y) ∼ (−-1)-εn d3y |⃗x − ⃗y |n−1 d--f(t,⃗y). (187 ) |⃗x − ⃗y| n n! dtn
This integral is divergent if we set the upper bound of the integral to infinity. In our formalism we take the upper bound of the integral as ∼ ℛ ∕ε and keep the ℛ dependence in the field. In the last step of the derivation, we let ℛ go to infinity if and only if this procedure gives finite result at least up to the relevant post-Newtonian order. At a high order of the retardation expansion approximation, however, some terms must have a lnℛ, and/or a n ℛ (n > 0 ) dependence. In this case, we can not let ℛ go infinite.

To solve this problem, it is important to realize that the field at (τ,xi) consists of two contributions: the retarded integral inside the near zone (the near zone contribution) and the retarded integral outside the near zone (the far zone contribution).

Since ℛ is introduced artificially, we expect that the far zone contribution to the near zone field must have some ℛ dependent terms which cancel out completely the ℛ dependent terms in the near zone. This expectation is the case and was proved to any post-Newtonian order by Pati and Will [129Jump To The Next Citation Point] within their formalism. They have shown that the total field (which is the sum of the near zone contribution plus the far zone contribution) is finite and independent of ℛ.

In this section we calculate the far zone contribution to the 3 PN equations of motion to make this article self-contained. We entirely follow [129Jump To The Next Citation Point162Jump To The Next Citation Point165Jump To The Next Citation Point], and the result is the same as theirs: The far zone field does not have any influence on the equations of motion up to 3 PN order inclusively.

For the near zone field, we write the field as

μν μν μν μν hN (C) = hN (N ) + h N(F) + hH , (188 ) ∫ Λμν(τ − ε|⃗x − ⃗y|,yk;ε) hμNν(N) = 4 d3y ----------------------, (189 ) N= {y:|y|≤ ℛ∕ε} |⃗x − ⃗y| ∫ Λμν(τ − ε|⃗x − ⃗y|,yk;ε) hμNν(F) = 4 d3y ---------------------, (190 ) F={y:|y|> ℛ∕ε} |⃗x − ⃗y|
where hμν N is the field in the near zone, hμν N (N ) is the near zone integral contribution to the near zone field, and μν hN (F) is the far zone integral contribution to the near zone field. Our task here is to evaluate hμNν(F) to the 3 PN order. In turn, this means that we should derive hμFν to lower order because the integrand Λ μν in the retarded integral for hμν N (F ) consists of μν h F.

Only in this section, we do not use our bookkeeping parameter ε while it should be understood that ⃗v is of order ε, and m of order ε2.

Now we evaluate the near zone contribution to the far zone field using a multipole expansion:

∫ 3 h μν = 4 -d-y--Λ μν(t − |⃗x − ⃗y|,⃗y) F(N) N |⃗x − ⃗y | ∑ l ( ) = 4 (−-1)-∂Kl 1M Klμν(u) , (191 ) l=0 l! r
where Kl is a collective multi-index, r ≡ |⃗x| is the distance from the near zone center to the field point, and u = t − r. The near zone multipole moments M Klμν are defined as
∫ M Klμν(u) ≡ d3yΛ μν(u,⃗y)yKl. (192 ) N

Next, the far zone contribution to the far zone field point can be evaluated as follows. The key idea would be an introduction of a new time u and may be seen from the following transformation of the retarded integral where the radial integral is transformed into a temporal integral from the past infinity to u = t − r:

μν ∫ 3 ′ Λ μν(t − |⃗x − ⃗x′|,⃗x ′) h F(F )(t,⃗x) = 4 d x ------------′------ ∫Fu ∮ |⃗x − ⃗x | ′ Λμν(u-′ +-r′,⃗x-′) ′ ′ ′ 2 = 4 −∞ du F t − u′ − ⃗n′ ⋅⃗x [r (u ,Ω )] dΩ, (193 )
where
(t − u ′)2 − r2 r′(u ′,Ω ′) = -------′----′--- . (194 ) 2 (t − u − ⃗n ⋅⃗x)
We then make STF decomposition of the integrand Λ μν in the retarded integral as Λμν ∼ fB,Lr− Bn⟨L⟩, where ⃗n = ⃗r∕r. The integrand in Equation (193View Equation) becomes a summation of terms, each of which consists of (some algebraic combinations of) near zone multipole moments (defined by Equation (192View Equation)) multiplied by terms which explicitly depend on t, u′, and Ω ′. Roughly speaking, the idea is that we do integral by parts many times, each time increasing the number of the time derivatives of the multipole moments, and assume that the system is sufficiently stationary in the past so that the contributions from the past infinity disappear. We then have for the far zone contribution to the far zone field point:
∑ ( )B −2 ∑ q hμν (u,xi) = 2- n⟨L⟩ 𝒟q (z)rq d-fB,L(u)- F (F) B⁄=2 r q=0 B,L duq l n⟨L⟩∫ ∞ ( s) ∑ dqf (u) + ---- f2,L(u − s)QL 1 + -- + n⟨L ⟩ 𝒟q2,L (z )rq----2,Lq--, (195 ) r 0 r q=0 du
with z = ℛ ∕r17, and
(− 1)q ∫ 1+2z (ζ − 1)q ∑q (− 2z)p 𝒟qB,L(z) = ------ --2-----B−-2AB,L(ζ,α )dζ − k(Bq−,Lp+1)(1 + 2z)------- (196 ) q! 1 (ζ − 1) p=0 p!
for B ⁄= 2 and
q+1 ∫ 1+2z ∫ 1−α q (−-1)---- q Pl(y)- 𝒟 2,L(z) = 2q! 1 (ζ − 1) dζ −1 ζ − y dy (197 )
for B = 2. Other quantities in the above equations are given by
∫ 1- 1 Pl(y)- AB,L (ζ,α) ≡ 2 ζ − y dy, (198 ) 1−α α ≡ (ζ − 1)(ζ + 1 − 2z )∕(2z), (199 ) dk(m)(ζ) --B,L----= k(Bm,−L 1)(ζ) for m ≥ 1, (200 ) dζ (0) -AB,L-(ζ,-2)- kB,L(ζ) ≡ (ζ2 − 1)B−2 for m ≥ 1. (201 )
Here Pl and Ql are the Legendre function of the first and the second kind. α represents an angular defect due to the fact that the far zone integral does not cover the whole spacetime due to the near zone. The function k(t) and the retarded time multi-derivatives of the STF coefficient fB,L comes from the recursive integrals by parts.

Then combining the near zone and the far zone contributions to the far zone field point, we have to the required order:

[ ( ) ( ) ( ) ] ( )2 00 P-0N DkN-(u)- 1- IkNl(u) 1- IkNlm-(u-)- PN0 hF = 4 r − ∂k r + 2∂kl r − 6∂klm r + 7 r , (202 ) [ i ( ki ) ( kli )] h0i = 4 P-N(u) − ∂ JN-(u-) + 1-∂ JN-(u)- , (203 ) F r k r 2 kl r [ ij ( kij ) ( klij ) ] ( 0)2 ij Z-N(u)- ZN--(u) 1- Z-N--(u) PN- ij hF = 4 r − ∂k r + 2∂kl r + r n , (204 )
where P0N = M 00, P iN = M 0i, DiN = M i00, IiNj = M ij00, JkNi = M k0i, J kNli= M kl0i, ZiNj= M ij, Zkij = M kij N, and Zklij = M klij N.

Next we evaluate the far zone contribution to the near zone field point. A transformation of the retarded integral (193View Equation) is again used and similar arguments below Equation (193View Equation) lead to the following formulae that we use

∑ ( 2 )B −2 ∑ dqf (t) hμNν(F)(t,xi) = -- n⟨L⟩ ℰB,L(z)q rq---B,L--- B⁄=2 r q=0 dtq l n⟨L⟩∫ ∞ ( s ) ⟨L⟩∑ q q dqf2,L(t) + ---- f2,L(u − s)Ql 1 + -- + n ℰ2,L(z) r -----q--, (205 ) r 0 r q=0 dt
with
q∫ 2z+1 q ∑q p ℰq (z) = (−-1)- -----ζ-----A (ζ,α )dζ − k(q− p+1)(1 + 2z)(−-1 −-2z)- (206 ) B,L q! 2z− 1 (ζ2 − 1)B−2 B,L B,L p! p=0
for B ⁄= 2 and
{ } q (− 1)q+1 ∫ 1+2z q 1 ∫ 2z+1 q ∫ 1−α Pl(y) ℰ2,L(z) = -------- ζ Ql(ζ)d ζ + -- ζ d ζ ------dy (207 ) q! 1 2 2z− 1 − 1 ζ − y
for B = 2.

Evaluating the coefficients q ℰB,L, we finally have

[ ∫ ∫ ττ i 10 τ ⟨kl⟩ ∞ (4) kl 8 τ ∞ (4) kk hN(F)(τ,x ) = ε − 8PN n IN(t − rζ)Q2 (ζ)dζ − 3PN IN (t − rζ )Q0 (ζ )dζ 1 ( ( 1) )] 4- τ(4)kl ⟨kl⟩ 8- τ(4) kk ℛ- 11 + 3P N IN (t)n + 3PN IN (t) 1 + ln εr + 𝒪 (ε ), (208 ) τi 9 h N(F) = 𝒪 (ε[ ), ( ( )) ] (209 ) kk 8 τ ∫ ∞ (2) k τ(2) k ℛ 9 h N(F) = ε − 16P N Z Nk(t − rζ)Q0 (ζ)dζ + 16P N Z N k 1 + ln -- + (ε )(,210 ) 1 εr
where we reintroduce our bookkeeping parameter ε, and ZijN is written with the near zone quadrupole moment as Zij= (1∕2)d2Iij∕d τ2 N N. We note that the fields h ττ of 𝒪 (ε10) and hμi of 𝒪 (ε8) are the 3 PN fields in our formalism. Finally assuming that in the distant past the binary was sufficiently stationary, we find that the far zone contribution becomes a function of time only at the 3 PN order. It turns out that only the spatial derivative of those 3 PN fields contributes to the 3 PN equations of motion. Thus the far zone contribution does not affect the equations of motion up to 3 PN order inclusively.

In this section, we have given a highly rough sketch about the method developed by Pati and Will [129Jump To The Next Citation Point] which is based on their previous work [165Jump To The Next Citation Point]. Readers may consult [129130162163165] for more details.


  Go to previous page Go up Go to next page